Powered by Max Banner Ads 

3 Reasons Why Your Blog Comment Wasn’t Approved | And Never Will Be!

by Jason Mathes on July 17, 2012

WordPress Logo - Proper Commenting

Nothing can make me more frustrated or pissed off than seeing a notification that I have a blog comment pending and find out it is SPAM. If you are just a casual visitor? Then you don’t need to worry. But if you have anything remotely related to a website or blog? Read this article or to the TRASH you’ll go!

The Issue - Desperate for Getting Found on the Web

I understand it. In today’s online world you want as many sites linking back to yours as possible. By having a large and diverse back link profile it will show a few things:

So one effective way is to post comments on other blogs, websites, forums, or anywhere else that could potentially link back to your site or blog. And although this is a good thing – this is also where the problems arise. Read below as to why your comment wasn’t approved – and probably never will be.

1. Lack of a Gravatar

If you run a website or a blog and plan on performing the above to try and build up your backlinks? You need to sign up for a Gravatar!  And it needs to be your face I see in the comment. If I see a generic stock image it is a big red flag that your SPAM and your comment is going in the Garbage. Of course this ONLY applies to those who are running a site or blog.

If your just a Casual Visitor? Don’t Worry About It – Please feel free to leave your comment!

For the Rest of you Aspiring Writers, Bloggers, and Web Masters?

Please at the very least get a Gravatar. It takes about 2 minutes to sign up and setup and you don’t have to worry about it again. It will automatically populate your face in any and all comments you make (at least with WordPress blogs). Of course there are a ton of other commenting systems that require you to setup a different profile – but if you are even half way serious? Start with the Gravatar – Please!

2. You Are Kissing My Ass

OK, I love it when someone has genuinely read the article and found it useful. I pretty much live for those rare gems in comments. But when you are blatantly just doing some major ass kissing it is obvious to me you A) Haven’t read my post. and B) Are just trying to stroke my EGO to get your Comment approved.

I know this can be construed as me being  judgmental but a blog isn’t a democracy. Although I try and be a nice guy as I want to see people succeed online. I will most likely trash your comment if I even smell the hint of poop in the air. (Sans my lil’ guy – were still working on his potty training.)

Spam Sucks

Gotta love Spammers!

3. You Haven’t Read the Article

Spam Bots are notoriously great at not reading the article. Or even better leaving a comment on an image instead of the article. Most of it gets tossed but it is still funny to see it in the SPAM folder.

The other one that drives me nuts is like the following example I received this morning:

A Really Poor Comment

A Really Poor Comment

This also applies to the one before this with the obvious brown nosing.  But what else was wrong?  This is an update for the PS3 for Call of Duty. Yes I know there is a version of the game for Apple and Android so it was kind of on topic (not really). But it was painfully obvious the person who commented didn’t take the time to actually read or understand what the article was about.

How to Fix It and Gain Visitors!

By this time I hope you have at least skimmed the first two points. So you have your Gravatar and you promise not to pucker up to the Tuchas – (TOO-khas) any more.

Don’t Miss: You should check out my Plugin Review on how to get your RSS Subscribers Back to Your Site!

If you are going to take the time to visit a website or blog with the sole intention of trying to get your DoFollow and run? Make sure to take the time and respect to read the ENTIRE article which for me takes about 45 seconds on avg (You guys with your 300 word articles – psh!).

Think of a comment that will:

  • A) Enhance the article in a way that will either start or go along with the existing “conversation” of the Comments
  • B) How you can relate to the material. For example – the recent Google Penguin algorithm change – how did it affect your site and your online business?
  • C) STICK TO THE TOPIC
  • D) Ask a Question. Get the Author engaged back in their own article.  But make sure it is related to the content you have just read.  Anything else should be directed to them through their Contact Me form.

If you do the above right? Not only will you make the author happy. You will get your back link. And if your comment draws real interest? You can end up getting visitors back to your site – possibly even the author yourself!

Another side benefit that I have been getting has been the opportunity to start building relationships with other blogs and finally start working on Guest Posting. Which if you can get a gig on a large blog? Can bring you a TON of traffic back to your own site!

Play By The Rules and We Both Win!

So even though I probably need to get another cup of coffee so I’m not quite so grumpy I hope you get the general idea. If you play by the rules above we both win in the end.

I’d love to hear what bugs you when people leave a “bad” comment and how do you deal with it?  Leave a Comment Below (Make sure to follow the rules!)

 

I'd Love to Hear From You!

Did the article you just read provide you with the information you were looking for? Still have a question? Or were you looking for something else entirely? Let me know by Commenting! You can use either the Facebook Commenting system or use the form below!

NOTE: Are you a Blogger or Website Owner? Make sure you read this first before commenting!

Sign Up for Free Updates!

Stay up to date with avgjoegeek.net. Sign up for the weekly newsletter. Or select "Call of Duty" to receive periodic updates about the game! Receive tips, tricks, and the latest updates!

I take your privacy very seriously
  • http://creately.com/blog Nishadha

    Blog commenting is an art which very few master. It is not just about the back link, its about building a connection with the blogger, improving your authority in the niche and host of other things. But as long as link building is there, there will be spam comments.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      True I have always attempt to leave a comment that is more than just the typical “Hey, Thanks for the great article!” and move on. If I took the time to visit the site I should respect the owner/author and leave a comment with the above.

      I have CommentLuv Premium and although it can be a SPAMMER’s dream – it is well worth the money spent on the SPAM that it ends up blocking!

      Thanks for the comment!

      • http://creately.com/blog Nishadha

        Yes, CommentLuv premium can be a spammers dream. I always have mixed feeling about the plug in but have to admit advantages far outweighs the disadvantages.

        • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

          Nishadha – I agree.

  • http://bloggingwithsuccess.net/ Ishan

    Gravatars! They are life savers when I have to scroll through spam to see if there’s a genuine comment.

    Regarding comments, raising an objection can also work well. It will get attention of other visitors and blog owner. This may draw traffic to your blog.

    Nice post, voted on Blog Engage.

  • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

    Yup – nothing says I have to agree with a post. But try and be constructive when doing that. Don’t just be a jerk! Post your reasons as to why you disagree with the article!

  • http://ineverwantedtobeafirefighter.blogspot.com/ Tim Casey

    I can say honestly I don’t suffer from your predicament Jason. I find myself much like an elderly person that enjoys junk mail because it is the only mail I get. I rush to my comments on the rare occasion they arrive with great hope. By the way what is a backlink?

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      Its become a personal pet peeve of mine Tim. Drives me nuts!

      What’s a back link? It is when you have another website link back to yours. You want a ton of diverse relevant back links linking back to your site. It helps your website in a lot of ways like I mentioned in the article. CommentLuv is great as you can leave a link from one of your articles in the comment section and it will automatically setup a back link from here back to your site!

  • http://oddblogger.com Abhi Balani

    Hey Jason,

    Do you know, a few days back, I shared the “Best Spam Comment Award” winner on my Facebook fanpage.

    The name was, “Best eyelash curlers” and the comment was so long that I had to delete around 1200 words to fit it in a status. Facebook didn’t allow me to publish an update with more than 62,000 characters. And the comment was completely irrelevant to the post.

    No gravatar is the one of the thing which really gives me a BAD impression about the commenters.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      Thankfully CommentLuv seems to solve most of those types of SPAM issues. GASP is an awesome spam blocker. But I did have to turn off trackbacks for the most part as 99% of them were junk links.

      Thanks for stopping by Abhi! – And folks if you haven’t yet – you need to check out his site http://www.oddblogger.com as he has some awesome content and contest giveaways on there!

  • http://www.creditdonkey.com/tip.html Theresa Torres

    Hi Jason,
    I’m not sure if my comment will be approved because I’m not using my own face but I’m still hoping for the best. Some bloggers prefer to use a different Gravatar to keep some sort of privacy I guess, like me.
    I don’t get a lot of comments on my personal blog and the few I have received are genuine ones so I don’t have issues with spam. I also try to leave relevant comments on blogs I visit. What saddens me is if I’m really interested in the topic, leaves a thoughtful comment and it gets ignored. It’s only recently that I’ve learned that Akismet may be the culprit because it seems that it’s been sending even genuine comments into the spam folder.
    Glad to see that you’re using GASP.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      I stopped using Akismet for that very reason!

  • http://www.blogpim.com Akporugo

    Blog commenting is the best in terms of seo benefit, when you look at the recent google algorithm it will simply tell you that forum posting is dead. I can not argue much but the point still remain valid due to the fact behind seo and i hope to say google still remain the gaint when it comes to web search. Sometimes when i do comment on blogs i see higher rankings in value compare to getting shitting links from the web, sure blog commenting is effective.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      Akporu you really need to get a Gravatar! Thanks for dropping by.

  • http://jahangiri.us/new Holly Jahangiri

    My friend Marian runs a page on Facebook called “Spomment of the Day.” You should contribute the best of the worst comments there, before deleting them.

    I love how some brilliant commenters have figured out that obsequiousness doesn’t work, so they try bopping you on the chin, instead. I love the ones that say, essentially, “It must take you long time write your posts. It is hard to write clearly on this topic. But if I am undrsnd you, it is wrong. Buy viagra.”

    Yeah. I know this post is going straight to moderation – hello. ;)

    Another fun one is when they call you by name, but get it wrong. So, Joe, thanks for your support in the BE contest. ;) (And thank YOU, Jason, I really do appreciate it.)

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      LOL Holly – you beat the Spam Bot and were automatically approved! (I’ll have to look into that… ;-p)

      Shoot – I wish I had known about that page! I had some doozies I just deleted last night! But since I have CommentLuv I’m sure I’ll be getting some more soon enough. This is one of the (small) downfalls of that plugin.

      Btw – good luck in the next BE Contest – I was dying reading your latest article! (BTW folks she has it linked – so click on it already!)

      As always thanks for stopping by!

  • http://www.moneymakingmodes.com Money Making Modes

    Nice points.

    Many spammers just visit the site and leave a comment in random post saying that they ‘liked’ it. They just don’t know the power of blog commenting technique.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      Yup – I was just hit with 25 Spam messages with “I liked it” with a URL inside the comment. So if you want your comment approved it better be real as I moderate everything because of morons like that.

      Thanks for stopping by and good luck with your site!

  • http://www.geeknoob.com Kundan Bhardwaj

    Rightly said Jason , but as a matter of fact most of the new bloggers like me don’t read the articles and is haste of backlinking we just leave a vague comment.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net Jason Mathes

      Unfortunately they will end up losing credibility and none of there comments will be approved!

  • http://www.jetsetgarmentbags.com Hannah Hamilton

    Blog commenting is a helpful SEO strategy for every blogger. Remember to always post relevant comments. Spamming will never take you anywhere.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      Hannah – I agree completely! Thanks for stopping by!

  • http://www.guideandnews.com Ehsan Ullah

    Having a Gravatar image is must in order to start blog commenting, but you know these days the spammers became more smart. I do get lots of spam comments using Gravatar image too.

    Well, Leaving a comment without reading the whole article is what I’ve also done when I didn’t know about the importance of blog commenting just to show off my face lol.

    Thanks for writing on this Jason.

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      Yes they are. I’m starting to think I might ditch Comment Luv just so I don’t have to deal with Spammers (as much?) I’m going to see how it is working for a friend’s blog first and then after the new year make the switch!

  • http://www.homeschoolbytes.com Misty

    Thanks for all the nuts and bolts info on commenting – and I enjoyed the bit of ranting :-) I often feel the same way myself.

    I have a small homeschool blog and am mostly self-taught, so I like learning from articles like these that have specific info for newbies like me – I’ll be checking out the ‘comment luv’ plugin.

    I’m also using Askimet, but don’t want to miss any genuine comments. When you quit using it, did you substitute something else, or just go to manual moderation of all comments?

    Thanks for helping a newbie,

    Misty

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      Hmm.. just noticed I never mentioned that! I use CommentLuv Premium which has GASP another type of SPAM plugin like Akismet. It seems to do a better on the false positives and about the same for the Spammers who visit. So at least I’m not losing any “good” comments any more :)

      The issue is that Spammers can outwit the plugins easily so I’m stuck moderating everything. I’d much rather be writing or responding to comments rather than having to filter out the garbage!

      Thanks for dropping by! I would highly suggest reading the latest guide I put together on how to make your blog Google Friendly. It has a TON of useful information there!

      And if you have any questions let me know – I’ll do my best and try to help you!

      • http://www.homeschoolbytes.com Misty

        Thank you for the tips – The Google article gives me a lot to go work on. Seems like there are endless tweaks to be done when blogging :-) I saw my traffic drop in half last October – from about 5000 hits a month to 2000 or so. I was wondering what I could do about it.

        After reading your article, I’m thinking of moving some ads below the fold, and also to see if I can make affiliate links ‘nofollow’. I often link to Amazon, as I write about lots of curriculum and books, but think that might not look so good to Google. Now to figure out a relatively painless way to change all my Amazon links to ‘no-follow’.

        Plus, I’ll be more careful that I link to sites that are related to my blog material.

        Thanks again for all the tips,

        Misty

        • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

          I would check Google’s Webmaster tools and see if anything strange is happening there to start. I thought that Amazon links were OK. But I do nofollow on other specific affiliate links.

          Good Luck!

  • http://simplebloggingnetwork.com Beth Hewitt

    Hi Jason,

    First time here. I have a gravatar so I pass the 1st test. The second test I’m struggling on because I like to me nice. Hmm maybe if I swear or something, or may you will think I am pretty or something.

    Comments should like you say add to the spirit of the blog post. Commenting whilst great for backlinks, in my opinion are more important for the relationships and opportunities available when you build up friendships with bloggers in similar niches.

    I hope I haven’t been too nice and spam-like. If I don’t pass I guess our friendship wasn’t meant to be. :(

    Take Care (oh no I don’t mean take care that’s sucking ass) Erm…Bigup!

    Beth :)

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      Beth – hahahha! You know what I mean about kissing a bloggers ass! Its that blatant “Oh, your blog is wonderful like unicorns and rainbows!” type comments that don’t add anything to the conversation!

      Thanks for the comment and for having a sense of humor :-)

  • http://thecodepost.in/ Sarthak Ganguly

    Relationships are what I consider most important. More than some backlinks. But I found that “bad_comments” image hilarious. Also the title of this particular page. :)
    By the way I have a question – I was wondering transferring my blog comments to commentluv, but I have read that spammers can screw it easily. Weighing discus and commentluv – you get the picture. So what would you suggest me? I currently am sticking with the default WordPress comments with Akismet installed. (That saved my life! 5000 spams blocked already!!!) :)

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      I’ve been using CommentLuv for a year now. After tweaking the settings and GASP? I have virtually little to no actual SPAM comments. If you use CommentLuv Premium? You won’t need AKISMET (which is notoriously bad at filtering good comments as SPAM btw) anymore.

      I like DISQUS but the extra step involved in having to either sign up for their service or using a social login could be a turn off to potential visitors wishing to comment on a post.

  • Joko Joseph

    Hi Jason,
    I was reading your Spotlight on blog egage. That’s how I linked up to your blog. I’m a newbie. I’ll put up my blog by this weekend. I hope to learn more from you.

    Have a great week

    • http://avgjoegeek.net/ Jason Mathes

      Thanks for dropping by! If you have any questions let me know I’ll be happy to answer them or point you in the right direction.

Previous post:

Next post: